It’s war in the Hamptons as Montauk locals rally against Cali hotelier over Surf Lodge rival
New York Post
Last updated: June 5, 2026
A controversy is brewing in Montauk, New York, over the planned opening of "Este," a two-story restaurant with rooftop access. Local residents are petitioning the East Hampton Town Planning Board, alleging that developers are attempting to operate a nightclub rather than the approved casual restaurant. The owner claims these accusations are fueled by competitors.
- Este was initially approved as a 39-seat cafe with 12 parking spaces. However, leaked documents suggest plans for a larger venue capable of accommodating up to 450 people and generating significant revenue, leading to concerns about it operating as a nightclub.
- Owner Marley Dominguez, who also owns the Offshore Montauk hotel, argues that occupancy numbers, based on square footage, are distinct from formal seating capacity and that the leaked documents were draft plans for private events, not the primary function of the establishment.
- Dominguez states Este will primarily be a co-working space and dining area, with limited entertainment and a closing time after sundown, except for private events, to avoid disturbing hotel guests.
- The East Hampton Town Planning Board is working to ensure Este operates strictly as a restaurant. Modifications to the approved square footage and venue size have been made by Dominguez to appease the town's concerns and bind the operation to restaurant use.
